Movies Like Be Careful What You Wish For

Loved Be Careful What You Wish For? These 24 movies and shows share its DNA — surfaced by our semantic engine from theme, mood, cast and genre, then ranked by how closely they match. Every pick includes cast, ratings, trailers and streaming options.

24 titles

Annabelle: Creation 2017 ★ 6.6

Let the Right One In 2008 ★ 7.5

The Unholy 2021 ★ 6.5

Evil Eye 2022 ★ 6.7

Annabelle 2014 ★ 5.8

Exorcismo Documentado 2012 ★ 7.3

The Wrath of Becky 2023 ★ 6.4

Abigail 2024 ★ 6.7

Hatching 2022 ★ 6.2

Cobweb 2023 ★ 6.4

The Haunting Hour: Don't Think About It 2007 ★ 6.8

Case 39 2009 ★ 6.3

Finders Keepers 2014 ★ 4.9

Wish Upon 2017 ★ 5.7

Robert 2015 ★ 4.3

Halloween 2007 ★ 6.2

Alice, Sweet Alice 1976 ★ 6.4

The Boy 2016 ★ 6.0

Halloween Kills 2021 ★ 6.4

The Communion Girl 2023 ★ 6.0

Marshmallow 2025 ★ 6.1

Annabelle Comes Home 2019 ★ 6.4

Worry Dolls 2016 ★ 5.3

Krampus 2015 ★ 6.2